"Send Them Back": the day the European Parliament applauded xenophobia... 1048
There are sometimes images that alone sum up an era. That of Members of the European Parliament, elected to defend the founding values of the European Union, chanting in chorus "Send them back!" at the end of the vote authorising member states to expel migrants to centres located outside European territory will remain one of the most disturbing.
This slogan, borrowed from the bluntest vocabulary of nationalist movements, goes far beyond the fight against illegal immigration. It does not only target people in an irregular situation. In the imagination of part of the European far right, it designates everyone unfortunate enough to be different: Africans, Arabs, Amazighs, Latinos, Muslims, refugees or simply foreigners. In a few words, a vision of Europe expresses itself: a closed, suspicious Europe obsessed with the purity of its borders.
The worst thing is not that this rhetoric exists — it always has and will probably continue to exist. The worst thing is that it now finds an echo inside the European Parliament chamber, with the complicity of traditional right‑wing parties that, out of electoral opportunism, conviction or perhaps simple stupidity, choose to echo far‑right themes rather than fight them.
Fine. "Send them back," they say. Let us therefore push this intellectual exercise to its conclusion.
Send them all back.
Send back the nurses who came from Africa and keep European hospitals running.
Send back the care assistants who look after the growing number of elderly people, many of them impoverished.
Send back the construction workers, bus drivers, cleaners, agricultural workers who harvest the fruits and vegetables.
Send back the couriers who feed those many people unable to do their own shopping.
Send back the engineers, doctors, researchers and students who enliven universities and hospitals.
Send back the foreign entrepreneurs who create businesses and pay taxes.
Send back the footballers and athletes who bring joy to young people and to nations.
Send them all back, these "undesirables", and find elsewhere, on another planet, those who will make Europe run tomorrow.
The demographic reality is merciless, members of Parliament. Europe is visibly ageing. Its fertility rate is below the generational replacement threshold in almost all countries. Former suppliers of labour and brains in Eastern Europe have become more prosperous; their inhabitants prefer to stay at home. The working population is shrinking while retirees are increasing. Health systems, pensions and public services already rely heavily on workers from immigration.
All the major international institutions remind us: without immigration, large parts of the European economies will lack labour in the coming decades. Not only are migrants not an economic burden, but they are often part of the solution to the demographic — and therefore economic — crisis threatening the continent.
The irony is striking: those whom some present as "undesirables" have precisely become indispensable to the daily functioning of your societies.
Sending them back en masse would weaken hospitals, transport, agriculture, construction, catering and a multitude of already strained sectors. The human and economic consequences would be considerable, sometimes disastrous.
Europe also seems to forget another historical truth.
For centuries, Europeans left their continent by the millions to seek a better life elsewhere: to the Americas, Australia or Africa. More recently still, millions of Europeans emigrated to escape wars, dictatorships or poverty. Today, the continent that long produced migrants wants to forbid others from following the same path.
This paradox reveals a troubling moral crisis.
The European Union likes to recall that it is founded on human rights, dignity and solidarity. These principles should not disappear as soon as the subject is immigration. Controlling borders is a sovereign right. Fighting people‑smuggling networks is a necessity. Organising legal migration is essential. But turning human beings into scapegoats and echoing slogans of hatred is a political and ethical failure.
When elected representatives applaud the cry "Send them back", they do not lower the people targeted. They surely demean the institution they represent.
A democracy is judged by how it treats its minorities, its foreigners and the most vulnerable. If the European Parliament becomes a platform where xenophobia is applauded, then the very idea of Europe is in danger.
Yes, send them back then... and then see who will treat your sick, build your housing, harvest your fruit, finance your pensions and keep an economy — already condemned by ageing to a shortage of labour — alive.
On that day, Europe may discover that those it called "undesirables" had, in reality, become indispensable.
And it may be too late to call them back. Their countries will also prosper sooner or later — as Ibn Khaldun reminded us.